Great By Choice: Uncertainty, Chaos, And Luck-Why Some Thrive Despite Them All

In a world where uncertainty is a constant, the ability of some companies to not only survive but thrive amid chaos is a testament to their strategic prowess. Jim Collins and Morten Hansen’s book, Great by Choice: Uncertainty, Chaos, and Luck—Why Some Thrive Despite Them All, explores the reasons behind the exceptional performance of certain organizations despite unpredictable conditions. This blog post provides a detailed summary of the book’s key concepts and insights.

Who May Benefit from the Book

• Entrepreneurs seeking long-term, stable business growth
• Corporate leaders navigating uncertainty or fast-changing markets
• Business students exploring research-based success principles
• Startups aiming to scale without losing focus
• Anyone wanting to lead with discipline, not just passion

---

Top 3 Key Insights

• Disciplined behavior beats luck or creativity: 10X leaders succeed with consistent action and data-driven decisions.
• The 20 Mile March ensures steady progress: Success comes from setting and hitting performance targets—no matter the chaos.
• Test small before going big: Great companies fire “bullets” (small experiments) before launching “cannonballs” (major initiatives).

---

4 More Lessons and Takeaways

• Productive paranoia builds resilience: Top leaders stay alert and always prepare for worst-case scenarios—even in good times.
• A SMaC recipe creates stability: Specific, Methodical, and Consistent practices lead to repeatable success.
• Return on luck matters more than luck itself: Both good and bad luck happen. How leaders react makes the difference.
• Level 5 ambition drives lasting greatness: Humble yet fiercely determined leaders focus on causes bigger than themselves.

---

The Book in 1 Sentence

Enduring greatness doesn’t come from bold moves or good luck, but from disciplined decisions, consistent action, and humble leadership.

---

The Book Summary in 1 Minute

“Great by Choice” answers why some companies succeed in chaos while others fail. The secret lies in what the authors call 10X leadership—leaders who show fanatic discipline, empirical creativity, and productive paranoia. These companies follow the 20 Mile March rule, progressing steadily despite uncertainty. They test ideas with small experiments before investing big and stay ready for the unexpected. Operational consistency through a SMaC recipe keeps them grounded. Most importantly, they react better to luck—both good and bad. At the center is the Level 5 leader—humble, determined, and focused on long-term success. These principles help any organization or individual thrive in unpredictable times.

---

The Book Summary in 7 Minutes

Success doesn’t depend on innovation, luck, or boldness alone. Collins and his team studied thousands of companies to discover what sets the best apart. The answer: disciplined leadership in uncertain environments.

Great by Choice: An Overview

In Great by Choice, Collins and Hansen delve into the factors that distinguish successful companies from their peers. They identified seven companies from 20,400 companies, filtered them through 11 rounds of cuts that not only outperformed their industry indexes by at least ten times over fifteen years but did so amidst rapid and unpredictable changes. These “10Xers” include:

• Amgen
• Biomet
• Intel
• Microsoft
• Progressive Insurance
• Southwest Airlines
• Stryker

The book contrasts these 10Xers with their less successful counterparts, using them as a case study to explore what makes some companies excel in times of chaos.

Key Components of 10X Leadership

The book outlines several core principles that set 10Xers apart from their competitors. These principles are:

Fanatic Discipline: The 20 Mile March

• Definition: Fanatic discipline involves unwavering adherence to core values, long-term goals, and performance standards, regardless of external conditions.
• The 20 Mile March Analogy: Imagine two explorers. Tom consistently covers 20 miles a day, no matter the weather, while Jack’s progress fluctuates dramatically. Tom’s consistent pace ensures predictable success over time.
• Characteristics of a Good 20-Mile March:
• Clear Performance Metrics: Well-defined and achievable goals.
• Consistency: Reliable progress irrespective of conditions.
• Sustainability: Long-term viability of the performance standards.
• Control: Maintainable effort that avoids overexertion or complacency.

Examples of successful 20 Mile Marches:

• Southwest Airlines: Achieving profitability every year for 30 consecutive years
• Progressive Insurance: Maintaining a 96% combined ratio
• Intel: Adhering to Moore’s Law

Empirical Creativity: Fire Bullets, Then Cannonballs

“Fire bullets, then cannonballs” is a core strategy used by 10X companies to innovate safely. It emphasizes testing ideas with small, low-risk experiments before making major investments. This method allows companies to reduce uncertainty, learn from small-scale feedback, and only scale up when there is clear evidence of success.

What It Means

• Fire Bullets: Conduct small, low-cost, low-risk tests to try out ideas.
• Assess Results: Analyze which bullets hit the mark and learn what works.
• Calibrate: Use data and feedback to refine the approach before scaling.
• Fire Cannonballs: Once validated, invest heavily and confidently in the successful strategy.

Why It Works

This approach:

• Encourages innovation with controlled risk
• Allows for learning through failure without major damage
• Enables quick adaptation to changing markets
• Helps avoid costly, untested, or ego-driven decisions

Real-World Examples

• Apple: Tested the music software (iTunes) and portable music player (iPod) before launching the full ecosystem that revolutionized digital music.
• Intel: Ran small experiments that led to a major shift from memory chips to microprocessors—a decision that defined its future.

Key Insight

10X companies weren’t necessarily more innovative than their competitors. They were just better at scaling the right innovations and avoiding uncalibrated big bets.

Productive Paranoia: Leading Above the Death Line

Productive paranoia sets 10X leaders apart. Even in times of success, they stay alert and ready for trouble. They channel fear into focused preparation, creating resilience in unpredictable environments.

Key Practices of Productive Paranoia

• Build Buffers: Create financial and operational cushions for tough times.
• Maintain Reserves: Hold conservative cash reserves to handle sudden shocks.
• Create Redundancies: Ensure backups exist for critical systems.
• Bound Risk: Set strict limits to avoid catastrophic losses.
• Avoid Death Line Risks: Steer clear of decisions that could destroy the company.
• Minimize External Exposure: Stay protected from factors beyond control.

The “Zoom Out, Then Zoom In” Technique

• Zoom Out: Step back to scan for emerging threats or big shifts.
• Zoom In: Act fast and focus deeply when facing a real danger.

Examples of Productive Paranoia

• Intel: Its culture was defined by the mantra, “Only the paranoid survive.”
• Southwest Airlines: Used fuel hedging to lock in low prices and survive oil price spikes.

Why It Matters

10X leaders understand that not all moments are equal. They prepare obsessively for crucial moments, giving them the edge when it counts. Their foresight allows them to capitalize on opportunities and navigate crises better than their rivals.

Build a SMaC Recipe

A SMaC (Specific, Methodical, and Consistent) recipe is a simple, clear set of core practices.

What It Includes

• Clear rules for decision-making
• Durable through time and turmoil
• Focused on what works repeatedly

Example – Southwest’s 10-Point System

Includes things like flying one type of aircraft, no seat assignments, and avoiding major hubs.

How to Create Your SMaC Recipe

• Identify successful actions
• Turn them into rules
• Follow them strictly
• Evolve them slowly and only with data

---

Return on Luck

Luck happens to everyone. What matters is how leaders respond.

Research Findings

• 10X companies didn’t get more lucky breaks
• They used luck better
• They also learned more from bad luck

Examples

• Southwest Airlines adapted fast after 9/11
• Progressive used a legislative setback as a growth opportunity

Recognizing luck, good or bad, and responding fast separates winners from the rest.

Level 5 Ambition

10X leaders show a rare mix of humility and intense ambition. Their drive isn’t for personal fame but for building something bigger than themselves. This selfless ambition is the core of Level 5 Leadership.

Key Traits of Level 5 Leaders

• Fierce Resolve: Stay locked on long-term goals, no matter the obstacles.
• Selfless Commitment: Put the company’s success above ego or personal gain.
• Credit Sharing: Celebrate team wins instead of taking the spotlight.
• Accountability: Take full ownership during failures or crises.

Examples in Action

• Herb Kelleher: Guided Southwest Airlines with humor, humility, and unwavering determination.
• Andy Grove: Built Intel through bold decisions and quiet discipline.

How They Build Enduring Greatness

• Set big, clear goals that inspire the team.
• Build strong leadership teams that carry the vision forward.
• Promote a culture rooted in discipline, consistency, and smart risk-taking.
• Stick with proven principles, especially during storms.

10X companies last because their leaders blend quiet confidence with bold vision. Their ego stays in check, but their ambition never rests.

Great by Choice Quotes

• “The signature of mediocrity is not an unwillingness to change; the signature of mediocrity is chronic inconsistency.”
• “We are not imprisoned by our circumstances…we are free to choose, free to become great by choice.”
• “The only mistakes you can learn from are the ones you survive.”
• “Luck is not is strategy, but getting a positive return on luck is.”
• “Luck favors the persistent, but you can persist only if you survive.”

About the Authors

Great by Choice is authored by Jim Collins and Morten Hansen, distinguished experts in business and leadership.

• Jim Collins is renowned for his work on what makes companies truly great. With a background in Mathematical Sciences and an MBA from Stanford University, Collins has authored several influential books, including Good to Great and Built to Last.
• Morten T. Hansen is a professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and INSEAD in France. Formerly an associate professor at Harvard Business School, Hansen’s expertise spans leadership and management, supported by his PhD from Stanford Graduate School of Business and experience as a consultant with the Boston Consulting Group.

Conclusion

Great by Choice offers a profound examination of what it takes to excel in a volatile world. By studying the behaviors and strategies of 10X companies, Collins and Hansen provide actionable insights for leaders striving to achieve excellence amidst uncertainty. Their research underscores the importance of discipline, creativity, vigilance, and a greater purpose in building resilient and successful organizations.